In August, prime minister Andy Burnham vowed to tackle the rot in the UK’s shopping areas, saying decades of deterioration had “hollowed out” high streets, leaving them “unrecognisable”.
For years, the British Retail Consortium, Business Improvement Districts (BIDs), and local authorities have pushed for ways to stop the decline of the nation’s high streets, where retail vacancy rates sit at around 13.4%.
To the average passer‑by, empty premises are an eyesore that drags down the appearance of shopping areas. “For the public, the look and feel of the high street is one of the biggest indicators of the market and the health of the country,” says Jen Lemen FRICS, partner at Property Elite.
October’s UK Autumn Budget raised the business rates threshold from £12,000 to £18,000 for retail, hospitality and leisure properties, as well as freezing rates in real terms for two years for the rest of the sector. It also removed business rates relief for vape and adult gaming centres from 1 April 2027. But for many it not go far enough, prompting the British Retail Consortium to say Chancellor John Healey gave “no breathing space for retailers … yet employment costs and business rates continue to rise”.
Yet the public narrative focuses less on tax burdens and more on the visible symptoms of closed shops, and long-term boarded up windows. The causes behind long‑term vacancies are complex but very often the landlord gets the blame. Iain Nicholson, founder of the consultancy, Vacant Shops Academy (VSA), argues that a caricature of the “greedy landlord” hides the reality.
“There is a myriad of reasons,” he says. “A landlord may be holding out for redevelopment. Upper‑floor occupiers might be covering the building’s costs. A former tenant could still be paying a historic rent higher than the market can now support. Or there may be complex financial arrangements with lenders that make a letting problematic.”
The physical nature of the retail stock has a role to play. Many vacant units are small, fragmented or poorly configured, and are not the large, flexible spaces that can be easily repurposed. “You can’t just wave a magic wand and reabsorb everything,” says Stephen Springham, partner and head of retail research at Knight Frank, adding that vacancies must be assessed asset‑by‑asset. “If you’re looking for solutions, you need to engage with those landlords.”
A new approach
In October, the government published Hope on the High Street, its new high street strategy backed by a £210m Community Assets Package to revitalise town centres, which includes reducing vacancies.
Meanwhile, the VSA is already putting a different model into practice – one of partnership. Founded in 2022, its methodology has roots in Nicholson’s work on the Portas Pilot scheme – launched by the government in 2012 with retail expert, Mary Portas. Over time, it has evolved into a structured four‑stage approach of audit, engage, encourage, promote, that has been implemented in 51 locations.
These stages are grouped under Nicholson’s ‘place partnerships’ – a collaborative model that brings together BIDs, councils, agents, landlords, chambers of commerce, cultural organisations and community groups. The aim is simple: to sweep aside the idea vacancy is a landlord or agent issue. Rather, it is a shared challenge requiring shared solutions.
There is a disconnect between landlords and tenants, when the two should work in the same direction, says Lemen, who believes shorter, more flexible leases mean the old hands‑off investor model no longer works well today.
She adds: “Landlords are better off helping tenants stay trading than facing more voids. Collaboration on small but critical issues such as poor lighting or unit perception, as well as footfall monitoring can prevent decline and support both sides.”
“The look and feel of the high street is one of the biggest indicators of the market and the health of the country” Jen Lemen FRICS, Property Elite
Unlocking units
One of the VSA’s newer initiatives, Get the Keys, takes a mixed public‑private team directly into priority empty units. The group assesses what types of occupiers could work, identifies barriers, and determines which partner, be it the council, landlord, agent or BID, needs to act
“What you see is different people bringing their specialisms and experience,” says Nicholson, adding that they work out together what could occupy the unit, which could be non-retail fits like health, wellbeing or arts, as well as what the barriers are, what needs to change, and importantly, who needs to play a part.
For surveyors, that may mean going into empty units to decide what could occupy them and what’s currently stopping them. There’s building surveying work, condition checks, measuring floor areas and judging whether a unit can be split or combined. And deciding what a change of use would involve, in terms of planning, accessibility or fire safety.
The VSA’s work reflects the broader shift in occupation, where pure retail is no longer the dominant force it once was. According to the Office for National Statistics, employment on high streets between 2015 and 2024 shifted significantly away from retail, which declined by 19%, as accommodation and food services grew by almost a fifth.
Bournemouth high street - September 2025
The policy debate: carrot vs stick
VSA’s methods of engagement are seen as less heavy-handed than the government’s, which introduced High Street Rental Auction (HSRA) in 2024; allowing councils in England to force landlords to bring long‑term vacant units back into use.
In January, Lewisham Council in London became one of dozens of local authorities to use the policy, when it designated Forest Hill as an HSRA location. “I’m supportive of something that brings about change and shakes the market up. But going after landlords and taking their properties away is draconian. It’s all stick and no carrot,” says Springham.
He admits to not having “a perfect compromise solution” but adds “I'm not sure the heavy-handed going after landlords” approach is right when circumstances for the vacant units are not fully known.
“Going after landlords and taking their properties away is draconian. It’s all stick and no carrot” Stephen Springham, Knight Frank
The media problem
Negative media coverage remains a major barrier in the perception of the health of the high street, with Colliers’ July report on the evolution of the high street stating that headlines often oversimplify complex realities. Nicholson bluntly labels it a “gloomster media narrative.”
The coastal town of Bournemouth has suffered from a string of recent bleak portrayals. Undoubtedly the loss of department store Debenhams, and national chains like M&S, and WHSmith has hit the town hard, but outlying retail parks, independent hubs, and a move towards leisure are signalling a shift in perspective.
“So much could be achieved through a well-planned, coordinated approach involving everyone. What is missing is a joined-up effort,” says Lemen, a former Bournemouth resident.
Far from terminal decline, Colliers suggests the country’s high streets are entering their next chapter, and in many respects, that journey is only just beginning. Nicholson concurs. Vacancy doesn’t go away, he says: “Circumstances change, owners change, trends change. Vacancy can come back. The only way to manage it is through partnerships and working together.”
As the prime minister turns his attention to the high street, hospitality, retailers and chartered surveyors wait to see how new policies will unfold. The challenges run deep, but the solutions, collaboration, transparency, realistic expectations and shared responsibility, are increasingly clear.
A bright future is possible, which is the goal of not just the VSA, but the sector. It will not come, however, from purely blaming landlords or waiting for government intervention, rather from the holistic work of rebuilding confidence; rethinking uses and re‑establishing the high street as a place people want to be.
RICS Influence & Advocacy Update - September 2026
Including discussions on business rates reform, planning and high street regeneration